Saturday, 24 October 2026

THE PRICE OF A SHORTENED IMPEACHMENT: When Political Expediency Threatens to Overtake the Search for Truth and Public Accountability

THE PRICE OF A SHORTENED IMPEACHMENT:
When Political Expediency Threatens to Overtake
the Search for Truth and Public Accountability


The decision of the House prosecution panel to withdraw three of the four articles of impeachment against Vice President Sara Duterte presents a disturbing question about the manner in which the Philippine political establishment understands its responsibilities to the people. What began as an extraordinary constitutional proceeding intended to examine allegations of misconduct, misuse of public resources, and abuse of authority has now been reduced to a single controversy concerning unexplained wealth. The prosecutors may consider this an intelligent tactical maneuver, a prudent economy of judicial time, or even a practical concession to the demands of an increasingly impatient public. Yet the development deserves consideration beyond the calculations of parliamentary strategy, because the larger question is whether the pursuit of a conviction has begun to displace the more fundamental obligation to establish the truth.

On October 13, the prosecution announced that it would abandon Article I, involving the alleged misuse of confidential funds; Article III, concerning alleged bribery within the Department of Education; and Article IV, relating to grave threats and other accusations arising from the Vice President's public statements. The Senate impeachment court, presided over by Senator Francis Escudero, accepted the withdrawal, leaving Article II, concerning unexplained wealth, allegedly deficient asset declarations, and prohibited business interests, as the sole remaining charge for adjudication. The prosecutors explained that the financial evidence was sufficiently substantial to justify concentrating their efforts on that article. There is an understandable legal calculation in such a decision, since a conviction on one article would be enough to produce the constitutional consequences of impeachment. Nevertheless, what may be sufficient for conviction is not necessarily sufficient for public accountability.

This distinction is neither academic nor insignificant. The nation did not arrive at the impeachment proceedings merely because somebody suspected that a high official possessed more money than could be satisfactorily explained. The controversy developed through a succession of questions about the expenditure of public funds, the behavior of officials entrusted with government agencies, the relationship between political power and administrative discretion, and the use of national security as a justification for expenditures ordinarily requiring a greater degree of public explanation. The original articles embodied a wider indictment of alleged conduct in public office. Their abandonment does not establish that the accusations were true; equally, it does not establish that they were false. It means, more simply and more troublingly, that three questions once considered sufficiently serious to be brought before the Senate will no longer receive an impeachment verdict.

There is an important difference between a prosecution that acknowledges deficiencies in its evidence and one that abandons allegations because it believes another charge provides a more convenient route to conviction. The former is a legitimate exercise of legal judgment, provided the decision is explained with candor. The latter risks transforming an impeachment proceeding into an exercise in political arithmetic. In ordinary litigation, a prosecutor may narrow a case to secure an attainable judgment. An impeachment trial, however, occupies a different constitutional and political position. It is not simply an adversarial contest between government lawyers and the accused. It is also an inquiry, conducted in the name of the Republic, into whether an official has betrayed the public trust.

The prosecution's confidence in the unexplained wealth article is not without an evidentiary basis deserving serious examination. Financial testimony presented before the impeachment court has raised questions concerning allegedly undeclared assets and income of the Vice President and her husband, Manases Carpio, with estimates ranging from approximately ₱817.87 million to ₱1.5 billion, depending upon the accounting assumptions employed. These figures remain allegations advanced through prosecution evidence and are subject to the defense's examination and explanation. If established under the applicable constitutional standard, they would constitute a matter of exceptional gravity. Public officers are required not only to declare their interests truthfully but also to demonstrate that public responsibility has not been converted into an instrument of private enrichment. The material presented therefore warrants rigorous judicial consideration rather than political dismissal.

Yet it is precisely because the financial article is so serious that the disappearance of the other allegations becomes difficult to justify on grounds of expediency alone. Unexplained wealth raises questions concerning the accumulation, ownership, and disclosure of assets. Alleged misuse of confidential funds raises a different question: how public money was obtained, distributed, expended, and accounted for. Alleged bribery concerns the possible corruption of administrative decisions through private inducement. Grave threats concern the conduct of an official wielding the authority and prestige of a constitutional office. These are related controversies, but they are not interchangeable offenses. To establish the existence of improperly disclosed wealth would not, by itself, explain how a confidential fund was utilized, whether government employees were improperly influenced, or whether the authority of public office was abused.

The original charges therefore deserved more than a calculation of which allegation appeared most likely to persuade the necessary number of senator-judges. They deserved examination according to their respective constitutional and institutional importance. Otherwise, the proceedings risk producing a verdict that determines the political fate of an individual while leaving unresolved much of the conduct that made the impeachment necessary in the first place.

Consider the question of confidential and intelligence funds. The original impeachment articles cited alleged irregularities involving ₱612.5 million in confidential funds associated with the Office of the Vice President and the Department of Education. The controversy included questions about disbursement, liquidation, the identities of recipients, and the adequacy of supporting documentation. These matters had already attracted substantial public attention because confidential expenditure occupies a peculiarly sensitive place in the management of government finances. Its secrecy may be justified by legitimate operational requirements, but secrecy can never be permitted to become a substitute for accountability. The taxpayer has a reasonable interest in knowing whether the safeguards governing public expenditure were observed, even when operational details cannot be disclosed indiscriminately.

The original investigation also presented a broader problem concerning the purposes for which such funds were sought. During the controversy over the Department of Education's confidential fund proposals, national security and the alleged danger of communist recruitment among the youth were invoked as justifications for expenditures in an agency principally responsible for education. There is nothing inherently improper in government recognizing genuine security threats. The objection arises when an expansive understanding of security permits ordinary governmental responsibilities to be treated as intelligence operations, particularly where the public has insufficient means of determining whether the corresponding expenditures were necessary, proportionate, and lawful.

This is where the country's recurring habit of employing anticommunism as a political explanation becomes especially relevant. The invocation of communist infiltration, subversion, or ideological recruitment has frequently occupied a prominent position in the nation's political vocabulary. Such concerns may sometimes possess a legitimate factual basis. They may also be stretched into convenient explanations for extraordinary administrative powers or restrictions upon legitimate dissent. The significant question in the present controversy was not whether the government should possess a capacity to defend itself against genuine threats, but whether the activities financed under the language of national security corresponded to legitimate functions and could withstand independent examination. Once the impeachment article dealing with confidential funds was withdrawn, that issue ceased to be one upon which the impeachment court would render judgment.

The danger is not confined to any single administration. When the classification of expenditure as confidential is allowed to diminish ordinary standards of verification, the resulting precedent can be exploited by succeeding governments irrespective of their political convictions. A department of education should not require the administrative character of a security establishment to perform its educational mission. A confidential fund should not become an informal budget insulated from meaningful scrutiny. Nor should an official be permitted to treat the assertion of national security as sufficient proof that public money was properly spent. If the allegations concerning the Vice President were unfounded, the proper examination of records and testimony would have helped establish that fact. If they were substantiated, the same examination would have strengthened the case for accountability. Either conclusion would have been more satisfactory than allowing the matter to disappear from the impeachment verdict.

Equally consequential was the allegation of bribery within the Department of Education. The article concerned claims that money was distributed to certain officials through envelopes, allegedly to influence procurement and financial decisions. The Vice President has disputed these accusations, challenging the sufficiency of evidence linking her to any unlawful payments or inducements. Nevertheless, the underlying issue reaches beyond the legality of individual transactions. It raises the possibility that the resources, appointments, relationships, and administrative machinery of a government department could be employed to cultivate personal loyalties, reward compliance, or discourage professional independence.

The issue of building a political power base within the bureaucracy is particularly important in a country where administrative institutions have often been exposed to personalistic politics. The civil service was never intended to function as the private following of an elected official. Department secretaries are custodians of institutions whose existence, legal authority, and financial resources precede their incumbency and must survive their departure. Procurement officers must be answerable to the law, not to the personal preferences of political superiors. Accountants must protect the accuracy of financial records, not accommodate the requirements of factional loyalty. The question of whether any such improper influence occurred during the Vice President's tenure at the Department of Education therefore deserved serious consideration, irrespective of whether the prosecution believed it possessed a stronger case concerning unexplained wealth.

The consequences of bureaucratic capture are familiar to the Philippine economy. Public procurement becomes vulnerable to favoritism, administrative decisions are made according to political considerations rather than institutional necessity, and career officials discover that obedience to personalities may be more rewarding than fidelity to rules. Such practices, wherever established, impose costs that are not always recorded in the national accounts. They appear in delayed projects, inefficient purchases, demoralized employees, poorly delivered services, and diminished confidence among citizens and investors. A government that cannot protect the independence of its administrative machinery will encounter difficulty persuading the business community that contracts, regulations, and public expenditures are governed by predictable standards.

The withdrawal of the article concerning grave threats raises another dimension of political responsibility. The Vice President's public statements involving President Ferdinand Marcos Jr., First Lady Liza Araneta Marcos, and former Speaker Martin Romualdez formed the basis of allegations that extended into questions of public intimidation and the conduct expected of a constitutional officer. Whatever the political animosities between the rival camps, the proceeding offered a formal opportunity to distinguish actionable misconduct from rhetoric, personal hostility, and political exaggeration. That distinction matters in a democratic society, for constitutional officers must enjoy freedom of political expression while remaining subject to the responsibilities and limitations attaching to their offices. Removing the allegation from adjudication leaves the impeachment court without the opportunity to pronounce upon its merits.

The abandonment of these three articles consequently presents the uncomfortable appearance of a retreat from the original reasons for demanding accountability. Months of public argument concerning confidential expenditures, questionable records, alleged inducements, national security justifications, and threats against high officials now appear to have been subordinated to the forensic attraction of a single financial charge. The prosecution may believe that it has simplified the case. The public may reasonably wonder whether the simplification has been purchased at the expense of a fuller accounting of the exercise of power.

This concern is sharpened by the legal consequences of the withdrawal. Articles I and IV were withdrawn with prejudice, preventing their revival in the impeachment proceedings within the applicable period identified by the Senate court. Article III, whose evidence had not yet been presented, was withdrawn without prejudice. These distinctions are significant because they illustrate that the decision was not merely a rearrangement of the presentation of witnesses. The prosecution surrendered the opportunity to obtain impeachment judgments on allegations that had formed part of the House's original case. It cannot be presumed that these allegations have been disproved, but neither can the prosecution continue treating them as though they were pending questions upon which the Senate will eventually decide.

The prosecutors have subsequently maintained that the withdrawn evidence need not be wasted, since appropriate records may be supplied to the Office of the Ombudsman or other agencies for possible proceedings under the law. This assurance is welcome insofar as it recognizes that withdrawal from impeachment does not resolve every other question of accountability. Nevertheless, an intention to furnish evidence to another institution is not equivalent to the completion of an investigation, much less a finding of responsibility. The public is entitled to know what records will be transmitted, what proceedings may lawfully follow, and whether the officials responsible for further investigation possess both the independence and the determination to pursue the matters according to their merits.

The prosecution must also recognize that its action has presented a political opportunity to the Vice President and her supporters. Her camp has already characterized the withdrawal as an admission that the accusations lacked foundation, while arguing that the Vice President was deprived of an opportunity to rebut the allegations and seek vindication before the impeachment court. That interpretation does not necessarily follow from the withdrawal, which is neither an acquittal nor a finding of factual innocence. Yet it would be politically naive to suppose that the distinction will prevent loyalists from employing the development as evidence of persecution or as a justification for dismissing the wider controversy.

There is an irony in this situation. Those wishing to hold the Vice President accountable now find themselves vulnerable to criticism not only from her supporters but also from those who believe the original charges should have been fully examined. The prosecution, by attempting to simplify its task, has supplied its adversaries with an argument that may prove more valuable politically than anything produced by another prolonged series of hearings. Its decision can be represented as proof that the original accusations were exaggerated, while the public is denied an impeachment judgment on their merits. Those who remain unwavering in their political allegiance to the previous administration may exploit this ambiguity, presenting tactical withdrawal as substantive exoneration and institutional restraint as vindication of their preferred narrative.

The danger becomes particularly grave when political loyalty is treated as a substitute for moral judgment. Supporters of any administration have the right to defend its record, challenge hostile evidence, and insist upon due process. They do not possess the right to demand that legitimate questions concerning public money be extinguished merely because their favored officials are involved. Yet there remains a deeply entrenched habit in Philippine politics of converting allegations of official misconduct into contests of personality, regional loyalty, and partisan identity. Under such conditions, accountability ceases to be considered an obligation owed to the Republic and becomes an inconvenience to be tolerated or rejected according to political affiliation.

The prosecution should have anticipated this reaction. An impeachment trial involving a Vice President with a substantial political following, a prominent family name, and an acknowledged place in the succession struggles surrounding the 2028 elections was never going to be insulated from partisan interpretation. For precisely that reason, the proceedings demanded greater completeness, procedural fairness, and intellectual discipline. Every abandoned charge creates room for competing narratives about why it was abandoned. Every unresolved allegation permits supporters and opponents to claim conclusions that the court itself has not reached. It is therefore possible for a prosecution to increase its probability of securing a conviction on one article while simultaneously diminishing the public credibility of the proceedings as a whole.

There is also the matter of the defense's right to be heard. The constitutional requirement of fairness cannot be set aside merely because public frustration has become pronounced. Where accusations have already been aired through testimony and documentary submissions, the respondent possesses a legitimate interest in challenging their accuracy and explaining the circumstances from which they arose. The defense's objection to the withdrawal therefore deserves consideration even by those who regard the allegations against the Vice President as serious. An accountable constitutional order cannot be built upon a proceeding in which the government is free to level accusations publicly but unwilling to permit their complete examination when doing so becomes inconvenient.

The difficulty is that the prosecution's interests and the public's interests are not always identical. The former may legitimately seek the most efficient means of establishing an impeachable offense. The latter encompasses the broader requirement that the state explain how its institutions were used, whether rules were observed, and what reforms may be necessary to prevent a recurrence of questionable practices. The public is not merely a spectator awaiting the result of a contest between opposing lawyers. It is the ultimate beneficiary of constitutional accountability. This distinction should have governed the House's judgment before it decided to place most of its original case beyond the impeachment court's consideration.

An additional concern involves the growing emphasis upon completing the proceedings before the Christmas recess. Statements by legislators and officials connected with the impeachment process have repeatedly entertained the prospect of a verdict before the year ends, while prosecutors have expressed hopes of a decision by late November or early December. Such expectations cannot automatically be equated with improper interference, since the Senate also has responsibilities concerning the national budget and its ordinary legislative calendar. The courts and Congress alike must maintain reasonable schedules. Nevertheless, a calendar becomes objectionable when its convenience is allowed to determine the completeness of a constitutional proceeding.[9]

The possibility that the impeachment trial might be concluded before Christmas invites a question of considerable seriousness. Has the political establishment become so impatient with the demands of accountability that the arrival of the Yuletide recess is to be treated as a more pressing consideration than the examination of charges already brought before the Senate? Public officials certainly possess the ordinary human desire to spend the holidays with their families, and the nation has an equally legitimate interest in avoiding a proceeding unnecessarily prolonged by procedural maneuvering. Yet public office involves obligations that cannot always be arranged around the conveniences of the legislative season. A prosecution concerned principally with finishing before Christmas risks conveying the impression that dispensing justice has been reduced to an administrative assignment which must be cleared from the docket before the year's festivities begin.

There is something particularly unfortunate about the appearance of such haste at a moment when the country continues to confront economic uncertainties, pressures upon public expenditure, and persistent dissatisfaction with the performance of political institutions. The Christmas season has considerable social importance in the Philippines, and its commercial significance is well understood by business establishments whose annual revenues depend upon consumer expenditure during the final quarter. Yet the constitutional business of the Republic is not a retail operation whose outstanding accounts must be closed before the holiday rush. The Senate's legislative calendar may accommodate a recess; the public's right to an honest and adequate determination of official accountability does not expire with the closing of the session.

No responsible observer should demand an interminable impeachment proceeding. Delays can diminish the value of evidence, increase the expenditure of public money, and encourage political exhaustion. A defense that deliberately prolongs proceedings without legitimate purpose would be open to criticism, just as a prosecution that introduces unnecessary witnesses or repetitive testimony would be failing in its duties. But the answer to excessive delay is sound case management rather than the abandonment of substantial allegations. The two are not synonymous. The Senate possessed procedural means to regulate the length of testimony, examine the relevance of evidence, and ensure that the parties observed reasonable schedules. The prosecution's decision to surrender three articles was a much more consequential measure than ordinary procedural discipline.

There is an economic consideration that deserves equal attention. The reputation of a government for integrity is an important, although often unquantified, element of the business climate. Investors examine financial indicators, foreign exchange conditions, market opportunities, infrastructure requirements, and the prospective profitability of enterprises. They also consider whether government agencies are reliable, whether public contracts are awarded according to ascertainable rules, and whether political influence can override lawful procedures. A state in which allegations of corruption receive only partial institutional examination may encounter greater difficulty establishing the confidence required for productive investment and long-term economic planning.

The cost of diminished confidence extends beyond foreign capital. Domestic enterprises, particularly smaller firms that possess neither political patrons nor access to privileged networks, depend upon impartial public administration. Honest suppliers are disadvantaged when procurement rules are manipulated. Taxpayers are disadvantaged when funds cannot be traced to legitimate public purposes. Workers are disadvantaged when financial resources intended for public services are diverted or inefficiently administered. Students are disadvantaged when the institutions responsible for their education become arenas of political controversy rather than centers of administrative competence. The prosecution's withdrawal of allegations involving confidential funds and procurement therefore touches questions of economic governance more substantial than the political fortunes of one official.

It is in this sense that the impeachment controversy must be understood as a political-business question. The relationship between public authority and private benefit has long been one of the central problems of Philippine development. The accumulation of wealth by officials is an obvious subject of concern, but the deeper danger lies in the conversion of governmental machinery into a means of personal advantage or political consolidation. An investigation concerned solely with unexplained wealth may illuminate one part of that problem. It does not necessarily explain the administrative methods, institutional weaknesses, and possible networks of influence through which an abuse of power might occur.

A conviction on Article II, should the evidence and the constitutional standard justify it, would carry substantial legal consequences. It would not, however, automatically produce a complete historical accounting of the other alleged misconduct. Conversely, an acquittal on Article II would not establish the innocence of the Vice President in relation to the three withdrawn articles. That distinction must be understood by the public and respected by political commentators on both sides. The constitutional requirement of a two-thirds vote for conviction is a formidable safeguard against the arbitrary removal of public officers. It also makes the quality and completeness of the case presented to the Senate especially important. The court must ultimately decide according to the evidence and the Constitution, rather than the political demands of either camp.

The 1987 Constitution begins its provisions on accountability with the declaration that public office is a public trust. That principle was not incorporated into the fundamental law merely to furnish an attractive phrase for ceremonial speeches. It imposes a standard of conduct upon the holders of public authority and establishes the premise upon which the institutions of accountability are justified. The Constitution also recognizes that impeachment judgment is limited to removal and disqualification, while liability under other laws remains a distinct matter governed by the applicable constitutional and legal rules. These provisions show that the removal of an official and the pursuit of legal responsibility are related but different functions of the state.[10]

The present controversy consequently demands more than assurances that the unexplained wealth evidence is sufficiently persuasive. The House prosecution should explain why allegations once presented as substantial grounds for impeachment have been withdrawn, how their withdrawal serves the public interest beyond the anticipated shortening of the trial, and what concrete institutional arrangements will ensure that the remaining questions are not abandoned. If the evidence concerning confidential funds, bribery, or grave threats is considered suitable for other lawful proceedings, the relevant agencies must be permitted to examine it independently. If particular allegations cannot be substantiated, that conclusion should be reached through an honest evaluation of evidence rather than hidden beneath a claim of procedural efficiency.

A further obligation rests upon Congress itself. Regardless of the verdict, the legislature should examine whether the rules governing confidential and intelligence funds sufficiently protect against unauthorized expenditure, whether audit procedures permit adequate verification without compromising legitimate security operations, and whether procurement and personnel safeguards are capable of protecting the civil service from political interference. These reforms would not require a finding of guilt against the Vice President. They would constitute a proper institutional response to weaknesses exposed by the controversy. Indeed, a responsible legislature should regard such corrective measures as part of the public value of an impeachment proceeding, rather than as incidental matters best forgotten after the political struggle has passed.

The deeper danger is that the House prosecution, in its effort to win an impeachment case, may have adopted too narrow an understanding of victory. A favorable verdict achieved through a shortened proceeding could be celebrated as a triumph of constitutional accountability, while substantial questions concerning the original accusations remain unresolved. An unfavorable verdict could be employed by the Vice President's supporters to discredit the entire impeachment effort, notwithstanding the fact that most of the accusations were never submitted for a final judgment. In either event, the nation could emerge from a costly and divisive proceeding without an adequate institutional explanation of matters that had occupied its attention for months.

The citizens who seek accountability are not necessarily demanding that the Vice President be condemned in advance of judgment. Many are demanding something more elementary and more consistent with constitutional democracy: that serious allegations be investigated fairly, that evidence be tested, that public money be accounted for, that the accused be afforded the opportunity to answer, and that the institutions entrusted with these responsibilities resist the temptation to subordinate their duties to political convenience. The same obligation would apply if the respondent were the President, a Cabinet secretary, a justice of the Supreme Court, or any other official entrusted with public authority.

That demand cannot be adequately answered by a prosecution that declares itself satisfied because one article appears strong enough to obtain conviction. The country is entitled to ask what became of the remaining allegations, what the original hearings established, and what consequences should follow from whatever evidence can legitimately be sustained. It is entitled to expect that the debates over confidential funds, national security justifications, the independence of government officials, and the possible misuse of bureaucratic authority were not merely episodes of political theater that could be discarded once another charge appeared more promising.

The expectation that the controversy should be settled before Christmas may provide a convenient conclusion to the legislative year. It may offer relief to exhausted prosecutors, defense counsel, senator-judges, and an impatient political establishment. But it will not, by itself, satisfy the demands of accountability. Nor will it prevent the supporters of the previous administration from exploiting the abandoned allegations as evidence of a politically motivated prosecution. Indeed, the narrower the adjudication becomes, the more room remains for partisan interpretations of questions that might otherwise have been examined in the open.

The responsibility of the political establishment is therefore to ensure that the conclusion of the impeachment trial does not become the conclusion of the search for truth. The financial allegations must receive a judgment supported by evidence and constitutional standards. The withdrawn allegations must not be casually represented as either proven wrongdoing or established innocence. The appropriate institutions must pursue the remaining questions wherever the law and available evidence permit. Above all, Congress must recognize that the confidence of the people in their government cannot be restored merely by producing a verdict before the holiday recess.

For a country that has endured repeated controversies over corruption, political patronage, the misuse of state resources, and the transformation of public institutions into instruments of factional advantage, the consequences of institutional failure extend far beyond the fate of one Vice President. The real danger is the gradual acceptance of a political culture in which allegations may be loudly proclaimed, extensively debated, and finally set aside whenever a more expedient course becomes available. Such a culture would leave public accountability dependent upon the convenience of those entrusted with enforcing it, rather than upon the lasting obligations of constitutional government.

The approaching Christmas season may bring the customary declarations of goodwill, reconciliation, and national renewal. These are respectable sentiments, but they cannot be made substitutes for the responsibilities of public office. The Republic is entitled to repose, but it is also entitled to answers. If the impeachment proceedings are to conclude before the year's end, their conclusion must be justified by the completion of the constitutional task, not by the convenience of the calendar. Otherwise, the prosecution's apparent success in simplifying the case may ultimately be remembered as a failure to pursue the full measure of accountability that the original accusations demanded.

The nation may eventually receive a verdict on the Vice President's alleged unexplained wealth. Whether it receives a satisfactory accounting of the wider controversy will depend upon what Congress and the other institutions of the Republic choose to do after that verdict has been rendered. It is upon this larger responsibility, rather than upon the speed with which the impeachment court reaches its decision, that the enduring political and institutional significance of the proceedings will have to be judged.

***

References and Source Notes

1. House of Representatives, Public Communications Bureau. (October 13, 2026). *House prosecution drops 3 impeachment articles, believes unexplained wealth charge enough to oust VP Sara.* https://congress.gov.ph/media/press-releases/10322

2. NewsWatch Plus. (October 13, 2026). *Impeachment court allows withdrawal of 3 articles vs. Duterte.* https://www.newswatchplus.ph/2026/10/13/impeachment-court-allows-withdrawal-3-articles-vs-duterte/

3. GMA News Online. (October 12, 2026). *Sara Duterte, husband's 'unexplained wealth' could reach P1.5B — witness.* https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/nation/1005657/sara-duterte-husband-s-unexplained-wealth-could-reach-p1-5b-witness/story/

4. Philippine News Agency. (August 4, 2026). *Initial evidence on confi funds shift 'burden of evidence' to VP Sara.* https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1281007

5. Manila Bulletin. (August 7, 2023). *VP Duterte defends DepEd's P150-M confidential funds; cites national security concerns.* https://mb.com.ph/2023/8/7/vp-duterte-defends-dep-ed-s-p150-m-confidential-funds-education-is-intertwined-with-nat-l-security

6. Manila Bulletin. (May 7, 2026). *A deeper look into the four articles of impeachment vs VP Sara.* https://mb.com.ph/2026/05/07/a-deeper-look-into-the-four-articles-of-impeachment-vs-vp-sara

7. House of Representatives, Public Communications Bureau. (October 20, 2026). *Luistro: evidence on withdrawn VP Sara charges will go to Ombudsman.* https://www.congress.gov.ph/media/press-releases/10331

8. GMA News Online. (October 14, 2026). *Sara Duterte camp: Withdrawal of 3 articles of impeachment means allegations 'lacked basis'.* https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/nation/1005862/sara-duterte-camp-withdrawal-of-3-articles-of-impeachment-means-allegations-lacked-basis/story/

9. Philippine News Agency. (October 19, 2026). *House prosecution hopes to see VP impeach decision by Nov or early Dec.* https://www.pna.gov.ph/article/house-prosecution-hopes-to-see-vp-impeach-decision-by-nov-or-early-dec

10. Republic of the Philippines. (1987). *Constitution of the Republic of the Philippines*, Article XI, Sections 1–3. Supreme Court E-Library. https://elibrary.judiciary.gov.ph/thebookshelf/showdocs/3/353